Transporting Bicycles: Bike Racks vs Cargo Carriers

Bike Carrier vs Cargo Carrier

Transporting bicycles requires careful consideration to ensure your bikes are secure and ready to ride when you arrive at your destination. Whether you're planning a weekend ride, a cross-country trek, or just taking your bike along for a quick trail ride, the carrier you choose for transporting your bike plays a big role in convenience and safety. Two mounting options stand out: hitch-mounted bike racks and cargo carriers. Each offers it's own benefits, but knowing which one fits your lifestyle and bike can make all the difference. In our quick guide, we'll explore these options and highlight how Let’s Go Aero (LGA) bike and cargo carriers making bike transport easier and more efficient than ever.

E-Bike Carrier on Truck Hitch

What is a Hitch-Mounted Bicycle Rack?

A hitch-mounted bicycle rack is a popular, convenient option for exclusively transporting one or more bicycles behind your vehicle. This type of bike rack attaches directly to the trailer hitch of your car, truck, or SUV, keeping your bikes stable and secure during the drive.

Benefits of Hitch-Mounted Bike Racks

  • Ease of Access: With bikes mounted with to an open hitch rack, loading and unloading are generally quick and easy. This is especially beneficial when you're frequently on the go or just need a quick rack for short trips.
  • Bike Capacity: Depending on the model and brand, these racks typically carry anywhere from one to four bikes at a time (with some specialty carriers able to carry even more). Let’s Go Aero’s V-Rack carriers, for instance, offer multi-bike transport solutions for varying needs starting with the BikeWing-2 Carrier for two bikes and the V-lectric which can carry up to 4 bikes. 
      BikeWing-2 Two Bike Carrier

      BikeWing-2 Two Bike Carrier

      Upgrade your bike transport with the BikeWing™ 2 Pro Tilting Two-Bike Rack, designed to securely carry two bikes with minimal frame contact for maximum protection. Its easy tilting feature allows full access to your vehicle's rear, making it the perfect companion for all your cycling adventures.

      Shop Now

    • Weight Capacity: Along with bike capacity, weight capacity is another factor, bikes come in varying weights and some bikes, like e-bikes, can weight more than standard bike carriers can carry. Looking at the racks we mentioned earlier, the BikeWing-2 can carry 40 lbs per bike and is best suited for standard bicycles. The V-Lectric on the hand can handle bikes up to 60 lbs and is a better choice for heavier bicycles like e-bikes. 

      V-Lectric Bike Carrier on RV

      V-lectric 3.0 E-Bike Rack

      The V-Lectric™ Pro is your ultimate solution for transporting e-bikes, designed to carry two heavy electric bikes with ease. With its sturdy frame and integrated tilt feature for easy vehicle access, it ensures your e-bikes are secure and accessible, perfect for every adventure.

      Shop Now

    • Versatility: Hitch-mounted racks come in platform and hanging styles, giving users flexibility. Whether you want a simple mount or an easy-to-load platform with ramps, the options out there are plentiful.
    • Minimal Interference: Since they sit behind the vehicle, these racks don’t interfere with roof space or wind resistance, making them more fuel-efficient than roof-mounted bike racks.

    However, bike racks aren’t without their drawbacks. They expose your bike to the elements and potential road debris, which can be an issue during long trips or unpredictable weather. Moreover, security might be a concern when your bike is in plain view. Though many bike racks come with locking capabilities, those with more expensive bikes or those going on long trips may feel more comfortable stowing their bikes inside of a enclosed carrier away from prying eyes.

    Enclosed Cargo Carrier with Bikes

    What is a Hitch-Mounted Cargo Carrier?

    A hitch-mounted cargo carrier is another versatile solution for transporting not just bicycles, but also other gear, making it ideal for those who need to haul multiple items on their trip. These carriers attach to the vehicle's hitch, providing a flat or enclosed space for storing gear. Let’s Go Aero offers a variety of hitch cargo carriers like the GearCage and GearSpace series, which are perfect for securing and protecting bikes.

    GearCage Carrier with Bike Rack

    Benefits of Hitch-Mounted Cargo Carriers

    • Protection: Enclosed cargo carriers like the GearSpace provide protection from rain, dirt, and road debris, keeping your bikes safe and clean throughout your journey.

      GearSpace Cargo Carrier on RV

      GearSpace Enclosed Cargo Carrier

      The GearSpace® 34 Enclosed Cargo Carrier offers 34 cubic feet of weatherproof storage, perfect for protecting your gear on any trip. Its slide-out platform allows for easy access to your bikes and belongings, making it a convenient solution for secure storage.

      Shop Now

    • Multi-Functionality: Unlike dedicated bike racks, cargo carriers can carry various items in addition to bikes, such as camping gear, coolers, or luggage. This is ideal for those with expensive or important bicycles, long trips or even van living.
    • Security: With a locked enclosed space, your bicycles are hidden from view, reducing the chances of theft and providing peace of mind during overnight stops or when you have to be away from your vehicle.
    • Customization: Many cargo carriers, including LGA’s GearCage model, allow for modular configurations to optimize space and meet your specific transport needs. You can even combine the the GearCage with Rack-IT V-Rack accessories to turn a cargo carrier into a multi-bike transport solution.

      GearCage Rack-IT Bike & Cargo Carrier

      GearCage T6 Hitch Rack

      The GearCage T6 Tilt-Up Cargo Rack is a versatile, open-frame carrier offering 300 lbs of capacity for hauling bulky items like coolers and camping gear. With Rack-IT Bike Rack Accessories (not included), this extra-large carrier becomes the ultimate multi-purpose adventure carrier.

      Shop Now

    While cargo carriers are excellent for protecting your bikes and gear, they typically have lower bike-specific capacity compared to bike racks as well as be more expensive than standard bicycle racks. Plus, installation and loading may take more time, especially for those unfamiliar with cargo carrier setups.

     

    Bike Carrier with 4 Bikes on car

    Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Bike Racks and Cargo Carriers

    From the number of bikes you have, to the type of car you drive, to the how far you are going—these are all factors that are going to impact your decision when choosing between a bike rack or cargo carrier for your bicycle transport. No all bikes racks fit on all vehicles or support the same bikes and its important to find a product that matches your needs and lifestyle.

    Number of Bicycles

    The number of bicycles you're transporting is going to be the first thing to consider when making your decision. If you're traveling with multiple bikes, a hitch-mounted bike rack is usually the more practical option, as it offers more space specifically designed to carry several bicycles at once. However, if you're transporting fewer bikes—particularly expensive ones—or need to bring along additional gear, a cargo carrier may be a better choice.

    Ebike Carrier on RV

    Vehicle Type and Compatibility

    Not all vehicles are compatible with every type of bike rack or cargo carrier. For smaller cars, a bike rack might be the only feasible option due to hitch limitations. Larger vehicles, like SUVs and trucks, offer greater weight capacities and often support a wider range of bicycle carrier as wells as cargo carriers.

    Ease of Installation and Use

    Both bike racks and cargo carriers are usually easy to install and use. Bike racks are typically quicker to install and load due to their exposed nature. Cargo carriers take a bit more time to set up, but once loaded, they offer the best protection and security.

    Security and Safety

    Bike racks leave bicycles visible, which can be a concern if you need to leave your bike on while awhile from your vehicle. Cargo carriers provide more discretion and security, particularly for overnight stops or in urban areas. However, some bike racks do come with locks (or have cable lock compatibility)to secure your bikes to the rack and the rack to your vehicle.

    Encloseg hitch carrier with bikes

    Cost and Budget

    Cost is always a consideration. Hitch-mounted bike racks tend to be less expensive than enclosed cargo carriers. That being said, if you need a versatile solution to transport not just bicycles but other equipment as well, a cargo carrier may provide more value in the long run.

    Frequency of Use and Travel Distance

    For those who use their bike rack everyday or for even short trips, a hitch-mounted bike rack offers convenience and simplicity. However, for longer trips where weather conditions, road debris and theft are a concern, a cargo carrier provides extra protection that might be worth the additional investment.

    Practical Scenarios

    When deciding between a hitch-mounted bike rack and a cargo carrier, it's essential to consider your specific travel scenarios. Different trips and cycling needs call for different transport solutions, whether you're heading out for a short ride or a long adventure.

    Cargo Carrier with Bike Rack

    Short Weekend Trips vs. Long Road Trips

    If you’re heading out for a short weekend trip, a hitch-mounted bike rack could be the perfect fit. Quick to install and easy to use, you’ll be on the road and cycling in no time. However, for long road trips where you need to protect your bikes and maybe even carry additional gear, a cargo carrier like Let’s Go Aero’s GearCage might be the better choice.

    Solo Cyclists vs. Family Outings

    For solo cyclists or couples, a hitch-mounted bike rack offers a streamlined, lightweight solution. But for longer family outings or camping trips, a cargo carrier provides the extra space needed for all the bikes, gear, and additional luggage.

    Urban Commuting vs. Adventure Travel

    Urban cyclists who need a reliable, easy-to-use system for quick inner-city may prefer the simplicity of a bike rack. On the other hand, adventure travelers who pack for more than just cycling will appreciate the versatility and protection of a cargo carrier.

    enclosed cargo carrier with bikes on van

    Bringing Your Ride to Life

    In the end, both hitch-mounted bike racks and cargo carriers offer unique benefits depending on your needs. Bike racks provide simplicity, ease of use, and affordability, while cargo carriers offer superior protection, security, and multi-functionality. When deciding which option is best for you, consider factors like the number of bikes, vehicle compatibility, and how you plan to use your carrier.

    Whether you’re heading out for a quick ride or embarking on a cross-country road-trip adventure, prioritizing safety and convenience will ensure your bicycles arrive ready for the ride. Explore Let’s Go Aero’s range of hitch bike racks and cargo carriers to find the perfect match for your cycling adventures.

    Ready to upgrade your bike transport setup? Check out our full range of bike racks and cargo carriers for the best in bicycle transport solutions.

    author

    About the Author

    Amanda Kennedy

    Camping Enthusiast & Product Tester

    Amanda Kennedy is an avid camper and captivating storyteller. Whether exploring new trails or writing about them, Amanda brings adventure and inspiration to every aspect of life.